Say goodbye to open brick-and-mortar stores on Thanksgiving

The news: Big-box retailers are bucking the decade-long trend of opening stores on Thanksgiving evening as an early kickoff for Black Friday.

  • Target said it will make Thanksgiving Day closures a permanent policy.
  • Other major stores like Walmart, Best Buy, and The Home Depot will close again this year but haven’t committed to a future plan yet, per the Wall Street Journal.

What this means: Early openings likely began as a way to get more consumers in stores to compete with the rising popularity of online shopping on platforms like Amazon. But now that these retailers have spent the pandemic beefing up their own ecommerce capabilities, many are finding the practice unnecessary.

While brick-and-mortar stores will still reign supreme on Black Friday itself, consumers are more open to shopping online on other days—including Thanksgiving.

Thanksgiving Day ecommerce sales will see the highest growth of all Cyber Five days this year, rising 20.7% to $6.10 billion, per our estimates.

Plus, the holiday shopping season is starting earlier and becoming more spread out, making it less important to stay open on a single day.

  • Over two-thirds (68%) of US adults planned to begin their holiday shopping before Thanksgiving this year, up from 61% in 2020, per Deloitte’s 2021 Holiday Retail Survey.
  • Retailers have responded by offering Black Friday deals as early as October—also due in part to the success of Amazon’s October 2020 Prime Day.
  • A tight labor market and supply chain issues could also be influencing retailer decisions this year.

Finally, keeping stores closed on the holiday can generate goodwill.

  • The practice of opening on the holiday has drawn criticism for keeping employees from celebrating with their families—and for doing the same to customers, who would have to give up time typically reserved for Thanksgiving dinner to head to stores for doorbusters.
  • A majority (72%) of consumers support retailers’ decision to keep stores closed on Thanksgiving, according to Deloitte’s Pre-Thanksgiving Pulse survey.

The bottom line: Though Thanksgiving Day store openings have been the norm for roughly a decade, the practice seems to be drawing to a close almost as soon as it began. Today’s rapidly changing ecommerce landscape and shifting consumer behaviors may be the nail in the coffin.

"Behind the Numbers" Podcast